GameFly
30 days free · $19.95/mo after
Exit grade A: Cancel yourself online in a couple of clicks, anytime.
On gamefly.com
We may earn a commission (via cj) - it doesn't change our verdict. How we get paid →
Then come back.
We'll track GameFly for you - reminders days before renewal, so deciding is always on your schedule.
Track this trialQuick answer
The GameFly free trial runs 30 days, then bills $19.95/month for the 1-Game Plan (one game or movie out at a time) plan. A credit card is required to start. Cancelling is easy - about 3 minutes. Our take: For roughly the price of one new game a year, GameFly turns buying into borrowing: unlimited game and movie rentals by mail across PS5, Xbox Series X, Switch, and 4K discs, no due dates, no late fees, and the option to keep any rental at a member's used-game price with the case and codes mailed to you for free.
Last verified: July 22, 2026
On gamefly.com
Our take
For roughly the price of one new game a year, GameFly turns buying into borrowing: unlimited game and movie rentals by mail across PS5, Xbox Series X, Switch, and 4K discs, no due dates, no late fees, and the option to keep any rental at a member's used-game price with the case and codes mailed to you for free. The 30-day free trial takes a card up front - a temporary hold, not a charge - and rolls into the 1-game plan at $19.95/mo unless you cancel first. The honest thing to weigh isn't the catalog, it's the cadence: because everything travels by mail, a full swap cycle runs most of a week, and the most common complaint we found is heavy players and new-release chasers waiting longer than they'd like - some read the pace as the queue quietly favoring lighter users. Whether that rhythm suits you depends on how you play, and the free month is the cleanest way to find your own mileage before a bill lands. Leaving is genuinely simple - you cancel yourself online, anytime - so the move is to try it, watch a couple of turnaround cycles, and set a reminder for day 29.
GameFly plans at a glance
| 1 game | 2 games | 3 games | 4 games | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly price | $19.95 | $27.95 | $34.95 | $41.95 |
| Discs out at once | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
| 30-day free trial | Yes | No, trial starts on the 1-game plan | No | No |
| Unlimited swaps, no due dates | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Verified 2026-07-17; prices are before tax. The 30-day free trial starts on the 1-game plan; 3- and 4-game plans open up to eligible members.
What you get
The GameFly 1-Game Plan (one game or movie out at a time) plan
Included · 6
Unlimited game and movie rentals by mail - one or two discs out at a time depending on your plan, across PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X|S, Nintendo Switch and Switch 2, plus 4K UHD and Blu-ray movies
A catalog of 8,000+ titles - from the latest releases down to deep retro back-catalog you can't stream anywhere
No due dates and no late fees - keep a rental as long as you want, then mail it back to pull the next title in your queue
Free shipping both ways in prepaid mailers
Keep-and-buy: if you love a rental, buy it at a member's used-game discount and GameFly mails you the original case and codes for free - no need to return that disc
A 30-day free trial of the 1-game plan to feel out the turnaround before your first charge
Worth knowing
Instant or digital play - GameFly's cloud game-streaming service shut down in 2018, so today it's physical discs by mail only; there's no download or stream tier
Fast turnaround - because titles travel by post, a full swap cycle (mail back, receive, ship the next) commonly runs most of a week, longer than a store run or a download
Guaranteed new releases on day one - hot titles are in high demand and can sit at low availability with a wait; the queue ships the next available game, not always your top pick
A charge-free trial by default - a card is required up front (a temporary authorization, not a charge), and day 30 converts to the paid 1-game plan unless you cancel first
A prorated refund when you cancel - cancellation is effective immediately and GameFly doesn't refund unused days, so time it near your renewal date
The honest data
By the numbers
- Trial length
- 30 days
- Price after
- $19.95 / mo
- Card required
- Yes
- Cancellation
- Easy
- Time to cancel
- ~3 min
Around the web
What others say about GameFly
Curated outside takes. We don't edit them, we just point at them.
At a glance
5 reviews from 5 sources
Topline: Mixed
1 positive2 mixed2 critical
Our read across dimensions
- Product quality
- Value
- Cancellation
- Honest billing
- Customer support
Reviewer
RocketRanker
Is GameFly legit, safe and worth it in 2026? - yes, for the right kind of player
“Frames GameFly as a strong deal for budget-conscious gamers who play a title and move on - a year of rentals costs about what four new games would - while calling out slow shipping and turnaround as the main trade-off.”
Independent editorial review; takeaway summarized from the piece.
Read on rocketranker.co.ukCommunity
Digital Addicts
A gamer's input: is GameFly worth it? - depends how fast you play
“A first-person gamer take that lands on 'worth it if you're patient': great for working through a backlog cheaply, frustrating if you want the newest game the week it drops.”
Independent gamer blog post; sentiment above summarizes the author's verdict.
Read on medium.com
Aggregate ratings
Cancellation guide
How to cancel GameFly
Documented · ~3 min
- 01
Sign in at gamefly.com and open your Account page from the top-right menu
- 02
Scroll to the bottom and select 'Cancel My Membership' on a desktop browser, then follow the prompts to confirm - cancellation takes effect immediately, and GameFly doesn't prorate or refund unused time, so cancel close to your renewal date
- 03
Mail back any titles you still have out within about a week of cancelling so you aren't charged a replacement fee for unreturned discs
- 04
Do this before day 30 of your free trial (or before your next billing date) so your card isn't billed the monthly rate - and if the cancel page won't load or the membership doesn't stop, email support@gamefly.com from your registered address and keep the reply as confirmation
GameFly free trial - frequently asked
- Is the GameFly free trial really free?
- Yes - the GameFly free trial is free for 30 days. A credit card is required, so it renews at $19.95/month unless you cancel first.
- How much does GameFly cost after the trial?
- After the free trial, GameFly costs $19.95 per month for the 1-Game Plan (one game or movie out at a time) plan.
- How do I cancel GameFly?
- To cancel GameFly: 1. Sign in at gamefly.com and open your Account page from the top-right menu; 2. Scroll to the bottom and select 'Cancel My Membership' on a desktop browser, then follow the prompts to confirm - cancellation takes effect immediately, and GameFly doesn't prorate or refund unused time, so cancel close to your renewal date; 3. Mail back any titles you still have out within about a week of cancelling so you aren't charged a replacement fee for unreturned discs; 4. Do this before day 30 of your free trial (or before your next billing date) so your card isn't billed the monthly rate - and if the cancel page won't load or the membership doesn't stop, email support@gamefly.com from your registered address and keep the reply as confirmation. It takes about 3 minutes and is rated easy to cancel.
- Do I need a credit card for the GameFly trial?
- Yes - GameFly requires a credit card to start the free trial, so note the renewal date - day 30 - if you only want the trial.
More Subscription Boxes trials
Book of the Month
Free
-
After
$16.99
Kept
-
“Skip any month free with no penalty — one of the most member-friendly subs on this list. (First hardcover for $9.99 (codes ROMCOM, BOOKBUD))”
Ipsy Glam Bag
Free
-
After
$14.00
Kept
-
“The lowest entry price in the beauty-box category, and the samples are legitimately deluxe-size. The catch is the cancellation timing: miss the 25th and you've bought another month. If you're sampling Ipsy as a one-and-done, set a calendar reminder for the 24th.”
The Fresh Cut Flower of the Month Club
Free
-
After
-
Kept
-
“A designed-bouquet club rather than a bulk-stems one: each month brings a single professionally arranged seasonal bouquet, several varieties plus greens, shipped UPS 2nd Day in an insulated box about a day after cutting. It reads as a recurring gift, the roughly $52.95 product cost becomes about $72.95 once the $20 shipping lands. Leaving is easy (online form, phone, email, or chat, cancel anytime, refund on anything unshipped) and gift plans do not auto-renew, so watch the monthly cutoff: stop the next delivery before the 1st. Keeping it going? Track your renewal here and we send a reminder before each one.”